37 Richards St
191 Columbia St
359 Van Brunt St
34 35th St Ste 6c
374 9th St
34 35th St
Fresh baked hand-formed crust filled with our fresh-squeezed key lime custard.
10" Pie
This is where it all started. We bake a hand-formed Graham crumb and butter crust and fill it with our key lime custard using 100% fresh-squeezed key lime juice. Typically serves 8.
$45.00 |
8" Pie
A smaller, guilt-free version of our 10-inch pie typically serving four. Careful, it will go fast.
$29.00 |
4" Single-Serve Tart
A single-serve version individually packaged. Throw a few in the freezer to satisfy those key lime urges.
$7.00 |
Box of 10 Tarts Pie
Five over Five. Eat a few now, freeze the rest for later or share.
$58.00 |
Our 4" tart frozen on a stick, hand-dipped in Belgian chocolate.
The Classic Swingle
Our coveted 4-inch tart, frozen upon a stick and hand-dipped in rich Belcolade chocolate, thinned with organic cocoa butter from our friends at Rakka Chocolate.
$8.50 |
The Raspberry Swingle
Same as the Classic with an added layer of rich raspberry puree.
$10.00 |
The Raspberry Blonde Swingle
Our Raspberry Swingle hand-dipped in Belcolade Belgian white chocolate.
$10.00 |
La Victoria Swingle
Same as the Classic but topped with a layer of La Morena chipotle puree before hand-dipping in chocolate. Feel the heat.
$10.00 |
The most delicious and cleanest REAL Whipped Light Cream available! A taste sensation sweetened with cane sugar that will brighten your key lime pie. Farmland's small-batch process creates a homestyle richness that you will proudly add to your family favorites.
14-oz Farmland Light Whipped Cream
Not everyone can just whip up some cream like Steve's wife Victoria (pictured here), so we're offering one of the premium aerosol brands available. Should be plenty for your 10-inch pie and little leftover just for fun.
$7.00 |
7-oz Farmland Light Whipped Cream
Not everyone can just whip up some cream like Steve's wife Victoria (pictured here), so we're offering one of the premium aerosol brands available. Should be plenty for your 8-inch pie and little leftover just for fun.
$5.00 |